Unexpected behavior using Mule Expression Language

mulesoft-logoWhile developing flows with a recent Mule ESB there is a big chance you will make use of MEL in your configuration. Although this feature has added great benefits while developing Mule flows it sometimes drives me crazy. In this post I will show two examples which took me some time to get it working.
The first was when I was using an expression-transformer to get a part of an XML document as payload. The expression I tried first was:

<expression-transformer>
  <return-argument evaluator="xpath" expression="//test" />
</expression-transformer>

I used the following xml as an example input:

<root>
  <test>
    <elementA>bericht</elementA>
  </test>
  <test2>abc</test2>
</root>

This results in an empty payload, not a NullPayload but an empty String as payload.
However if I define my transformer like the following:

 <expression-transformer expression="xpath('//test')"/>

it results in a Dom4J Object as payload with the following String content:

<test><elementA>bericht</elementA></test>

which was exacty what I needed. I haven’t checked the source code to see if it could be clarified or explained somehow but it is good to know this difference in behavior.

The other example I ran into had to do with checking if a message property existed in a choice expression. I wanted to see if a incoming message (SOAP/XML) had an attachment attached to it. This becomes visible in the Mule Message as a ‘cxf_attachments’ property at the INVOCATION scope. So I first tried it with the following MEL expression:

 
<when expression="#[header:INVOCATION:cxf_attachments?==null">

I also tried several alternatives of this expression but I couldn’t get it to work. So I used the ‘old-fashioned’ way that could be used before MEL was in place:

 
<when expression="message.getInvocationProperty('cxf_attachments') != null" evaluator="groovy">

This worked like a charm. So you see that although MEL does add nice features I sometimes find it difficult to determine how it behaves in certain situations.

About Pascal Alma

Pascal is a senior IT consultant and has been working in IT since 1997. He is monitoring the latest development in new technologies (Mobile, Cloud, Big Data) closely and particularly interested in Java open source tool stacks, cloud related technologies like AWS and mobile development like building iOS apps with Swift. Specialties: Java/JEE/Spring Amazon AWS API/REST Big Data Continuous Delivery Swift/iOS
This entry was posted in Mule3 and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.